Chronology:I Am Not Your Broom

From This Might Be A Wiki
Song name Run time Releases Year Differences from other versions
I Am Not Your Broom (Demo) 0:33 1996 Includes only the first half of the song, up until the end of the lyrics. The melody is also a bit different, and the broom voice isn't as deep.
I Am Not Your Broom 1:04

No! 2000  
I Am Not Your Broom (Podcast Version) 1:24

Even Numbers 2 (Podcast Episode) 2008 This version uses a piano rather than an accordion and features John Flansburgh singing as the broom.