Difference between revisions of "Talk:Giants Jubilee"
From This Might Be A Wiki
m |
|||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
Should we put [[Giants Jubilee]] and [[Mightathon]] on song pages under Album? Or were they left off deliberately? - Herwwiyal 10:40, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | Should we put [[Giants Jubilee]] and [[Mightathon]] on song pages under Album? Or were they left off deliberately? - Herwwiyal 10:40, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | ||
| − | :They are listed under [[:Category:TMBG Collections]] (as is [[Dial-A-Song | + | :They are listed under [[:Category:TMBG Collections]] (as is [[Dial-A-Song: 20 Years Of They Might Be Giants]]) because they are each a collection of [[:Category:Singles And EPs|Singles and EPs]] from the [[The Pink Album]] and [[Lincoln]]. --[[User:Badqueso|badqueso]] 11:25, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) |
::Actually, I meant putting them on individual Song pages, as we have done with the other compilations. - Herwwiyal 12:07, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | ::Actually, I meant putting them on individual Song pages, as we have done with the other compilations. - Herwwiyal 12:07, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | ||
:::Ah, sorry. I think it's because Giants Jubilee and Mightathon are just what the non-album stuff from the first and second disc of [[Then]] are called. Not really actual albums. I guess it would be equivalent to putting Dial-A-Song Disc 1 and Disc 2 on the pages: pretty excessive when Dial-A-Song - 20 Years Of They Might Be Giants is on them as well. It seems the only way they were sold was electronically. Most likely for those who wanted the bonus/EP stuff, but already had the first two albums. So I look at it more as buying half of a CD, like a la carte shopping, not as a separate entity. I hope what I wrote makes sense. --[[User:Badqueso|badqueso]] 12:28, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | :::Ah, sorry. I think it's because Giants Jubilee and Mightathon are just what the non-album stuff from the first and second disc of [[Then]] are called. Not really actual albums. I guess it would be equivalent to putting Dial-A-Song Disc 1 and Disc 2 on the pages: pretty excessive when Dial-A-Song - 20 Years Of They Might Be Giants is on them as well. It seems the only way they were sold was electronically. Most likely for those who wanted the bonus/EP stuff, but already had the first two albums. So I look at it more as buying half of a CD, like a la carte shopping, not as a separate entity. I hope what I wrote makes sense. --[[User:Badqueso|badqueso]] 12:28, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | ||
::::Made Sense to me. Thanks for explaining - Herwwiyal 12:41, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | ::::Made Sense to me. Thanks for explaining - Herwwiyal 12:41, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT) | ||
Latest revision as of 17:20, 8 March 2007
Is it my imagination, or did Giants Jubilee (as well as Mightathon) only contain the bonus tracks off Then until recently? MooseBlaster 13:01, 21 Nov 2004 (EST)
Should we put Giants Jubilee and Mightathon on song pages under Album? Or were they left off deliberately? - Herwwiyal 10:40, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT)
- They are listed under Category:TMBG Collections (as is Dial-A-Song: 20 Years Of They Might Be Giants) because they are each a collection of Singles and EPs from the The Pink Album and Lincoln. --badqueso 11:25, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT)
- Actually, I meant putting them on individual Song pages, as we have done with the other compilations. - Herwwiyal 12:07, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT)
- Ah, sorry. I think it's because Giants Jubilee and Mightathon are just what the non-album stuff from the first and second disc of Then are called. Not really actual albums. I guess it would be equivalent to putting Dial-A-Song Disc 1 and Disc 2 on the pages: pretty excessive when Dial-A-Song - 20 Years Of They Might Be Giants is on them as well. It seems the only way they were sold was electronically. Most likely for those who wanted the bonus/EP stuff, but already had the first two albums. So I look at it more as buying half of a CD, like a la carte shopping, not as a separate entity. I hope what I wrote makes sense. --badqueso 12:28, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT)
- Made Sense to me. Thanks for explaining - Herwwiyal 12:41, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT)
- Ah, sorry. I think it's because Giants Jubilee and Mightathon are just what the non-album stuff from the first and second disc of Then are called. Not really actual albums. I guess it would be equivalent to putting Dial-A-Song Disc 1 and Disc 2 on the pages: pretty excessive when Dial-A-Song - 20 Years Of They Might Be Giants is on them as well. It seems the only way they were sold was electronically. Most likely for those who wanted the bonus/EP stuff, but already had the first two albums. So I look at it more as buying half of a CD, like a la carte shopping, not as a separate entity. I hope what I wrote makes sense. --badqueso 12:28, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT)
- Actually, I meant putting them on individual Song pages, as we have done with the other compilations. - Herwwiyal 12:07, 21 Jun 2006 (MDT)
