Template talk:Vocal

Oh god I hope other people agree that creating a page for each non-guitar or non-bass to say there's no guitar or bass part is pointless and needlessly takes up space. I mean, sure, lyric instrument pages are great because everybody feels comforted by the lack of a redlink and gets to learn that when the Sung-By says instrumental, it really means it... but do we really need pages for each instrument a song does not feature? Is red space so daunting? (Not to mention that this template only applies to the small handful of A Capella's but is probably intended for / would open the door to songs without guitar tabs that don't necessarily only contain vocals.) Sorry Ant, but I vote "Meh." ~ magbatz 01:55, 7 August 2009 (UTC)

well, i was rather unsure of it myself, but i talked it over with brad and he seemed to think it was alright. my thought was that it would apply to other things as well, like spoken things (clock radio announcements), and/or interviewish things (frank doris cunningham). idk, it just seemed like something that might be handy. sure there'll still be plenty of red, but less. -- 02:36, 7 August 2009 (UTC)

I do think it's a bit much though. I think we should just kill the idea. --Duke33 03:38, 7 August 2009 (UTC)